Israel Week was sidetracked in such an ironic way.

Dr. Norman Finkelstein was denied tenure this weekend from DePaul. It wasn't surprising but absurd. Finkelstein is one of the pre-eminent scholars on the Jewish Holocaust and the Israel/Palestinian conflict. Raul Hillberg, the world's leading scholar on the history of Jews in Europe, had this to say about the tenure.

"It takes an enormous amount of academic courage to speak the truth when no one else is out there to support him. And so, I think that given this acuity of vision and analytical power, demonstrating that the Swiss banks did not owe the money, that even though survivors were beneficiaries of the funds that were distributed, they came, when all is said and done, from places that were not obligated to pay that money. That takes a great amount of courage in and of itself. So I would say that his place in the whole history of writing history is assured, and that those who in the end are proven right triumph, and he will be among those who will have triumphed, albeit, it so seems, at great cost." It must be mentioned that

Hillberg is no lefty, he is a right winger through and through.


Avi Shlaim, Professor of international relations at Oxford University, who is regarded as one of the world's leading authorities on the Israeli-Arab conflict, said this about Finkelstein.

"His last book, Beyond Chutzpah, is based on an amazing amount of research. He seems to have read everything. He has gone through the reports of Israeli groups, of human rights groups, Human Rights Watch and Peace Now and B'Tselem, all of the reports of Amnesty International. And he deploys all this evidence from Israeli and other sources in order to sustain his critique of Israeli practices, Israeli violations of human rights of the Palestinians, Israeli house demolitions, the targeted assassinations of Palestinian militants, the cutting down of trees, the building of the wall -- the security barrier on the West Bank, which is illegal -- the restrictions imposed on the Palestinians in the West Bank, and so on and so forth. I find his critique extremely detailed, well-documented and accurate.

Then there is Noam Chomsky. ptI

pt. II


How it all started. pt.I
If you watch this you will understand, outside of it being about Israel/Palestine, why I admire Finkelstein’s debating skills. He is like a pit bull constantly holding back. Remember too that he is debating Harvard’s head law professor, one of the men who got O.J. off. Notice how much Dershowitz tries to change the subject from his plagiarism. Finklestein’s research is meticulous and impeccable.

pt.II

Dershowitz wasn’t able to take down Chomsky, due to work in linguistics, so Finkelstein is his proxy.